Appealing the Dismissal of a Chapter 13 Bankruptcy (2024)

Learn when you might want to appeal the dismissal of your Chapter 13 bankruptcy case and how to do it.

By Baran Bulkat, J.D. · California Western School of Law

The bankruptcy court can dismiss your Chapter 13 case for many reasons. In most cases, you can file a new bankruptcy right away. But sometimes it can be in your best interest to appeal the dismissal order to a higher court for further review.

To learn more about what happens if the court dismisses your Chapter 13 bankruptcy, see When a Bankruptcy Case Is Dismissed.

Reasons the Court Might Dismiss Your Chapter 13 Bankruptcy

When you file for Chapter 13 bankruptcy, you must be honest in your paperwork, follow all bankruptcy rules and procedures, and make all of your required Chapter 13 plan payments. Otherwise, the court can dismiss your case without a discharge.

In general, the court might dismiss your Chapter 13 bankruptcy because of:

  • procedural mistakes such as your failure to file the correct forms, provide supporting documents, or attend required court hearings
  • failure to make your Chapter 13 plan payments, or
  • willful misconduct such as disobeying court orders, lying on your bankruptcy paperwork, hiding assets, or otherwise abusing the bankruptcy process.

For more information on specific reasons that can cause the court to dismiss your bankruptcy, see Reasons the Court Might Dismiss Your Bankruptcy Case.

The Court Can Dismiss Your Bankruptcy With or Without Prejudice

A bankruptcy judge can dismiss your case with or without prejudice. Here is the difference.

Bankruptcy Dismissal Without Prejudice

If your case is dismissed without prejudice, it means that you can refile immediately. Unless you disobey court orders, abuse the bankruptcy system, or engage in other intentional misconduct, the court will typically dismiss your case without prejudice. In general, if the court dismisses your case without prejudice, it's usually a better idea to simply refile your case rather than appeal the dismissal.

Bankruptcy Dismissal With Prejudice

If you engage in willful misconduct or file for bankruptcy multiple times to delay your creditors, the court might decide to dismiss your bankruptcy with prejudice. Depending on the judge's order, a dismissal with prejudice can have significant consequences including:

  • time limits on when you can file for bankruptcy again, and
  • restrictions on which debts you can discharge (eliminate) in a future bankruptcy filing.

Because a dismissal with prejudice can have several negative consequences, it might be worthwhile to appeal the decision to a higher court for further review.

To learn more about dismissals with and without prejudice, see What Does Dismissed With Prejudice Mean? and When Your Bankruptcy Case Is Dismissed Without Prejudice.

Appealing a Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Dismissal

In order to appeal a Chapter 13 bankruptcy dismissal, you have to file a notice of appeal within 14 days after the court dismisses your case. If you need more time, you can file a motion with the court to request an extension.

After filing the notice of appeal, you must file additional paperwork that outlines the reasons why you believe the bankruptcy court should not have dismissed your bankruptcy. In addition, you must attend a hearing to explain your reasons to the judge in person.

Because of the complicated nature of the appeals process, you will normally need an attorney to help you. But keep in mind that appealing a Chapter 13 bankruptcy dismissal can be very costly and you might not be successful unless you can prove that the bankruptcy judge committed a legal error.

Appealing the Dismissal of a Chapter 13 Bankruptcy (2024)

FAQs

How to stop dismissal of Chapter 13? ›

Dismissal and Starting Over

You can file again as soon as you qualify for either Chapter 7 or Chapter 13. This will also involve filing a separate motion with the court to ask for an extension of the automatic stay, assuming that you file within a year of the dismissal.

Can you negotiate with creditors after Chapter 13 dismissal? ›

Experiencing a bankruptcy dismissal can be an overwhelming experience, especially when creditors start reaching out to you for payment. One way to handle this is through debt settlement. Debt settlement is negotiating with creditors to reorganize the debt by agreeing on a payment schedule.

What are the benefits of voluntary dismissal of Chapter 13? ›

Chapter 13 Voluntary Dismissal

An unexpected illness or sudden job loss can result in you not being able to make your monthly payments. Dismissing your Chapter 13 case and refiling can restart your three to five year payment plan and reduce your monthly payments.

How to get out of Chapter 13 early? ›

It's designed so you'll pay the amount you can afford. Therefore, the court will only let you complete your Chapter 13 bankruptcy early under two conditions: You can pay everything you owe in full other than long-term obligations like mortgages, or you can prove a financial hardship.

What happens if my Chapter 13 gets dismissed? ›

When your bankruptcy case is dismissed, you lose benefits and could be left worse off than before you filed your Chapter 13 case. Your debts will not be discharged. Your debts are discharged in Chapter 13 only when you complete your plan, which can last three to five years.

What does it mean when a Chapter 13 case is dismissed? ›

Dismissal of a Bankruptcy Case – Dismissal ordinarily means that the court stopped all proceedings in the main bankruptcy case AND in all adversary proceedings, and a discharge order was not entered. Dismissal can occur because a debtor requested the dismissal and qualifies for voluntary dismissal.

Can you dispute a dismissed bankruptcies? ›

And even when they aren't willing to work with you, you're usually able to refile immediately if your case is dismissed without prejudice. If you want to appeal the dismissal rather than refile, you will have to file a notice that you are appealing with the court within a couple of weeks of the dismissal.

How long does a Chapter 13 dismissal stay on your credit? ›

How long does a Chapter 13 bankruptcy stay on your credit report? In most cases, a Chapter 13 bankruptcy stays on a credit report for up to seven years after the bankruptcy filing date. Once the seven years have passed, the bankruptcy should come off credit reports automatically.

How soon can I refile Chapter 13 after dismissal? ›

In the event that your bankruptcy was dismissed without prejudice, as is the case with most dismissals, you can refile immediately. This is very common for those who accidentally make errors when filing their paperwork or fail to meet certain qualifications.

What is the difference between a Chapter 13 dismissal and a discharge? ›

When a debt is discharged through bankruptcy, your credit reflects that you no longer have to pay the debt. You can begin the process of slowly building up your credit, free from most debt. With a bankruptcy dismissal, however, all of your debts are reopened on your credit.

Can you walk away from a Chapter 13? ›

Chapter 13 – See Bankruptcy Code Section 1307 – A debtor has a right to dismiss its Chapter 13 bankruptcy case if the bankruptcy began as a Chapter 13 case, but the court may place restrictions on a debtor's ability to file a subsequent bankruptcy case.

Does Chapter 13 trustee monitor income? ›

Trustees do not monitor your income during the course of your repayment. However, a trustee possesses what Ginter terms “broad powers” and responsibilities. They include: Determining if you qualify for Chapter 13 bankruptcy.

What happens to unsecured debt if Chapter 13 is dismissed? ›

Once a bankruptcy case is dismissed, the automatic stay is no longer in effect. That means creditors can take all collection action allowed by law. Collection activities may include collection letters, debt collection lawsuits, wage garnishments, repossessions, and foreclosures.

What is the lowest payment on Chapter 13? ›

If you filed for bankruptcy to avoid foreclosure or are behind in house payments, your Chapter 13 plan payment could be more or less $1500 per month. Additionally, high income, high debt Chapter 13 filers would usually be required to make payments between $2000 and $3000, or even more.

Do you pay 100% in a Chapter 13? ›

This is known as a percentage plan and can vary from 1% - 99%. A 100% plan indicates that the petitioner does not qualify for debt reduction based on their income and ability to pay. This Chapter 13 plan structures 100% of that client's debt to be paid back through the repayment process.

How long does it take to refile a Chapter 13 after dismissal? ›

If your Chapter 13 bankruptcy case was dismissed, you could refile. However, you will need to wait 180 days if any of the following apply to your case: You voluntarily dismissed the case after a Motion for Relief was filed. The case was dismissed with prejudice.

How soon can you file Chapter 13 after Chapter 13 dismissal? ›

The law says that a person who has received a “discharge” in bankruptcy must wait several years before being eligible for discharge in another case. However, if you were in a Chapter 13 case that was dismissed before you received a discharge, then this limitation doesn't apply. You would be free to refile immediately.

What is a Chapter 13 dismissal refund? ›

Getting a Refund After Dismissal

As you make payments under your repayment plan, the money goes to your bankruptcy trustee, who then distributes it to your creditors. If your case is dismissed, you are entitled to a refund of any money that is still in the trustee's possession.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Wyatt Volkman LLD

Last Updated:

Views: 5917

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (66 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Wyatt Volkman LLD

Birthday: 1992-02-16

Address: Suite 851 78549 Lubowitz Well, Wardside, TX 98080-8615

Phone: +67618977178100

Job: Manufacturing Director

Hobby: Running, Mountaineering, Inline skating, Writing, Baton twirling, Computer programming, Stone skipping

Introduction: My name is Wyatt Volkman LLD, I am a handsome, rich, comfortable, lively, zealous, graceful, gifted person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.